Friday, July 8, 2011

Temp to Perm: The New Employment Model

Friday, July 08, 2011

As organizations have cut back on permanent full time jobs, many employers have turned to “temps” as a means to supplement the remaining positions and to fill in when extra help is needed.  This is really not a new trend; organizations have been using “temporary workers” for decades. What may be new is that “temping” has become a permanent way of life for some.

In an era when all jobs seem to be “temporary”, the proposal that there are individuals who choose to make a career of temporary assignments may not be so absurd. When employed by a large international human resources consulting firm here in Atlanta, I once had an IS development project team which included a member who had chosen to work strictly temporary IS project assignments north of I-285. Between assignments she used the downtime to rejuvenate herself.

In a 2010 report published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, it is estimated that by 2008 the temporary employment service industry had come to account for some 2.3 million workers. The chart below, taken from the 2010 report shows that over the period from 1990 to 2008 temporary serice workers grew exponentially while total employment gained 20% over that same 18 year period.


In addition, during this same period of time, the nature of temporary assignments changed. In the early days of the temporary service industry, the nature of the work was mainly clerical and industrial. However, by the 1990’s more and more professional roles were to be seen in the ranks of the temporary worker. Attorneys, engineers, physicians, and others could be found as “temps”.

While “Office and Administrative” job classifications continue to make up over 20% of the temporary service industry workforce, “Healthcare practitioners” now make up almost 5% of those 2.7 million workers. It might seem to the outsider that “temp” jobs pay very little, actual temporary wages mirror market place wages very closely. Take for example the average temporary salaries of “Management” workers in the temporary area at almost $98,000 in 2008.

It is true that most temporary work assignment have fewer employee benefits than permanent full time jobs. However, as the demand for temporary workers has grown, some temporary employment firms have begun to offer traditional benefits on a limited basis. Temporary workers with in-demand skills often find themselves working for temporary employment firms for extended periods of time in a similar relationship to any other employment situation.

For some individuals, the value of a temporary assignment is that they get to “try out the job” while at the same time the employer gets to “test drive” employee. The advantage is that organizations which do not fit the employee’s style are weeded out and employees who do not fit into the company’s culture are identified up front. This avoids the uncomfortable situation where a new employee has to be released and lessens the likelyhood that an employee finds themselves back on the street.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Accountable Care Organizations A.K.A. HMO?

Friday, July 01, 2011

“On March 31, 2011, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) released proposed new rules to help doctors, hospitals, and other providers better coordinate care for Medicare patients through Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).” 

“Under the proposed rule, an ACO refers to a group of providers … that will work together to coordinate care for the patients they serve …. The goal of an ACO is to deliver seamless, high quality care for Medicare beneficiaries. … a patient-centered organization where the patient and providers are true partners in care decisions.”

Last year’s Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) provides for a number of policies to assist providers in improving patient safety and quality of care, hopefully making health care affordable. Through the Medicare Shared Savings Program, ACO’s with lower health care cost, and achieving certain performance standards, will be financially rewarded. The goal is to create incentives for providers to work together in a coordinated manner across all health care channels to provide quality and affordable health care to Medicare beneficiaries. If successful, this model could be adopted by other public plans as well as private insurers and employer’s sponsored health care plans.

Some of concepts of an Accountable Care Organization sound very similar to those of the initial attributes of the early Health Maintenance Organizations. Both organizations strive to deliver well coordinated, quality care in a cost effective manner. Philip Betbeze, writing for HealthLeaders Media, in a November 15, 2010 article was quoted as saying “standardized care is better care, and that hospitals, physician practices, rehab centers …will deliver better care if it is coordinated, and if financial penalties or rewards accrue to those organizations producing better outcomes”.  Thirty years earlier, Dustin Mackie and Robert Biblo writing in the American Journal of Law and Medicine in 1980, stated that, “the health maintenance organization (HMO), whose primary goal is to provide quality medical service in a cost efficient manner”.
 
ACO's and HMO's Both organizations have the capability to organize themselves into legal entities to provide end to end health care for individuals as well for public and private health care plans. Such organizational structures include the well known “(IPAs) while others may prefer a physician-hospital organization (PHO)”. Consider that both organizations expose themselves to financial risk by accepting the “accountability” for delivering total patient care. Likewise, HMO’s agree to accept capitation in return for meeting the HMO member’s medical needs.

The initial HMO concept of a “gate keeper” made perfect business sense up to the point when members wanted more personal choice in the selection of their primary care physician, pharmacy, hospital or physical therapist.  Forced to receive their medical care through a single sources, large numbers of employees, and their health care plan sponsoring employers abandoned HMO’s for the semblance of managed care in the form of PPO’s.

Only time will tell the fate of Accountable Care Organizations.

Friday, June 24, 2011

Workplace Wellness Programs

Friday, June 24, 2011

It is almost impossible to read a newspaper, professional publication or view much television without becoming aware of the lack physical health of the American population. The American public is constantly reminded that we eat too much and exercise too little.  Increasingly, organizations are faced with workforces which struggle with various chronic illnesses and poor behavioral and lifestyle choices.  For over forty years we have been told that smoking is bad for us, yet over 23% of adult males and 17% of adult females continue to smoke in America.

As part of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) $10 Million has been made available to fund creation of workplace wellness programs through the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. These funds will be used to address risk factors associated with chronic diseases such as heart disease, cancer, stroke, and diabetes. The funds will be channeled through a competitive bidding process of contracts to a nationally based organization with the ability to work with employers to develop or expand workplace wellness programs. Efforts will be directed at educating employees about good health practices promotion of physical activity, proper nutrition, tobacco cessation, and changes in behavioral patterns and lifestyle choices.

Do workplace wellness programs work? The answer is both “Yes” and “No”.  In those workforces which are stable with low rates of turnover, an employer may have many years to work with employees to educate, modify behavior, and provide incentives designed to foster better health and healthy lifestyles. However, in those employers where turnover is high and the workforce is very unstable, the ability of an employer to affect change may be very limited.

Since employees join organizations at all stages of life, it is only reasonable to assume those employees will bring with them a varied lifestyle, health and exercise history, and nutritional culture. Workplace wellness programs must overcome years, if not decade’s worth of poor health history and lifestyle choices. Since it took years to establish an employee’s health behavior, it will require years to change many of the ingrained life style choices. Consider that at any given time over 30% of smokers are “attempting” to quit. If all of these smokers were to be successful, consumption of cigarette, pipes, and cigars would be virtually nonexistent. Unfortunately, it often takes several attempts before a smoker quits and the recidivism rates are high. In one study, “Smoking Cessation, by Sherri Sheinfeld Gorin, Ph.D., it was report that on average, it required 2-3 attempts before the smoker successfully quit.

Ultimately the individual must accept responsibility and accountability for managing their own health behaviors and lifestyle. While governments and employers can provide both disincentives and incentives for employees to change their behaviors, employees themselves are the only ones who can move to take action.

Friday, June 10, 2011

The State of 2011 Social Security

Friday, June 10, 2011

In a 244 page report dated May 13, 2011, the Social Security Board of Trustees released their 2011 report on the financial status of the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Disability Insurance (OASDI), otherwise known as Social Security. In their report, the Trustees Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OAS) funds are projected to be exhausted in 2036. The Disability Insurance (DI) funds are expected to be exhausted in 2018. The report also projects that OASDI program costs will exceed non-interest income in 2011 and demand for program benefits are expected to remain higher than normal when compared to the program’s 75-year history.

The signcanace of the report, the 71st such report in the life time of the Social Security, is that those employer sponsored programs which are integrated with Social Security benefits could see a rise in their own costs if Social Security benefits are reduced. Take for an example a defined benefit pension plan which offsets 50% of the retirees monthly pension benefit with Social Security benefits. Assume two otherwise equal retirees, “A” who retirees before a reduction in Social Security benefits and “B” who retires after a reduction in Social Security benefits.

Assume the Social Security benefits for retiree “A” was unreduced at $1,300 monthly and one year later Social Security benefits for retiree “B” was reduced at $1,100 monthly. The plan’s simplified monthly pension benefit formula is: 75% of Final Average Monthly over 36 months, times Years of Service over 20, less 50% of the retirees estimated Social Security Award amount at age 65. Both retirees were age 65, their Normal Retirement Age for Social Security and the private pension plan.


In the above simplified example, a 15% reduction in the retiree’s estimated Social Security Award amount leads to a 5% increase in the retirees pension benefit and a 2% decrease in Income Replacement Ratio for “B”. While a 5% increase in the retirees pension benefit may seem small, consider this for hundreds or thousands of employees who will consider retirement in the coming years. Consider also the poor performance of the current financial markets and you may see that changes in Social Security benefits (Social Security Reform) has a potential ripple effect into any private employer sponsored defined benefit pension and long term disability plans which offset (integrate) Social Security Award amounts.

Friday, June 3, 2011

CMS Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notice Requirement

Friday, June 3, 2011

Effective with current plan years, Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notices which informs eligible members of plans which provide prescription drug coverage that those plan do or do not provide creditable coverage, must provided those members that notice no later than October 15th annually. Previously, Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notices were required by no later than November 15th annually. The Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notice requirement was a function of the Medicare Modernization Act of 2003 and is required of organizations and "entities" who provide prescription drug coverage to Medicare Part D eligible individuals.

The CMS has provided model Medicare Part D Creditable and Non- Creditable Coverage Notices in both English and Spanish. The change in the date is associated with the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) which changed the Medicare enrollment period beginning in 2011. The new Medicare enrollment date is October 15 through December 7, annually. Thus the Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notices must be in the hands of Medicare Part D eligible members by October 15 to allow them time to make their enrollment choices.

CMS also provides access to the archives of 28 prior Creditable Coverage Guidance and Notices for those organizations or entities who are required to retroactively provide such notices. CMS also provides access to various instructions and related forms for use in determining creditable coverage and reporting coverage disclosure requirements to the CMS.

The Medicare Modernization Act (MMA) requires entities (whose policies include prescription drug coverage) to notify Medicare eligible policyholders whether their prescription drug coverage is creditable coverage, which means that the coverage is expected to pay on average as much as the standard Medicare prescription drug coverage. For these entities, there are two disclosure requirements:

A written disclosure notice is required for all Medicare eligible individuals on an annual basis who are enrolled under an organization’s prescription drug plan. (Prior to October 15th) Notices are also required at the time a Medicare eligible individual joins a covered plan.

A disclosure is provided to:

• Medicare eligible active working individuals and their dependents
• Medicare eligible COBRA individuals and their dependents
• Medicare eligible disabled individuals and their dependent
• Medicare eligible retirees and their dependents

The Medicare Modernization Act requires late enrollment penalties for those persons who fail to maintain creditable coverage for a period of at least 63 days following their initial enrollment in the Medicare prescription drug program. Thus, Medicare Part D Creditable Coverage Notices are essential to the individuals decision as to whether or not to enroll in the Medicare Part D prescription drug program.

Organizations sponsoring prescription drug programs, creditable or not are required to complete the Online Disclosure form disclosing to the CMS whether or not their program meets the creditable coverage guidelines under the Medicare Modernization Act.

The Disclosure must be completed:

• No later than 60 days from the beginning of each plan year
• Within 30 days after termination of a prescription drug plan
• Within 30 days after any change in creditable coverage status

Friday, May 27, 2011

The State of Private Pensions

Friday, May 27, 2011

In March 2011, the US government’s General Accountability Office (GAO) released a report on the status of US private pension plans. Under the title, “Private Pensions: Some Key Features Lead to an Uneven Distribution of Benefits”, the GAO reviewed the state of both private Defined Contribution (DC) and Defined Benefit (DB) plans. Not surprisingly, the report stated that over 90% of the new plans formed were DC plans, creation of DB plans were primarily associated with professional level organizations, and the impact of the current financial crisis on retirement savings is largely unknown. The report was initiated at the request of US House Representatives Sander M. Levin, Richard E. Neal, and Charles B. Rangel, all members of the House Ways and Means committee.

In the opening paragraph of the report’s cover letter back to the three Representatives, the GAO reports that private pension plans account for a tax revenue loss of $105 billion for FY 2011 and an estimated loss of $602 billion for FY’s 2012 through 2014. The cover letter goes on to report that tax favored private pension plans have peaked at approximately 50% of eligible employers. This peak has occurred in the face of numerous legislative attempts to make it more attractive for employers of low income workers to implement tax favored plans and for low income workers to save. Furthermore, the cover letter raised the concern that much of the benefits of some tax favored plans are being garnered by highly compensated employees (HCE) and not lower income workers.

The stated purpose of the GAO’s review, other than at the request of the three representatives, was to:

• Identify the trend in private pension plan in recent years.
• Identify the “characteristics” of DC plan participants “at or above the” statutory limits.
• The potential impact on “low income” workers of savings’ incentives.
• The long term impact on the recent economic crisis on savers.

In general, human resources management is one of the most legislated activities with regulations occurring from the municipality to the Federal level. Specifically, regulations associated with private pensions have seen decades of legislative enactment activity; the most notable was the passage of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). The stated and unstated goal of all of this action was to encourage employers to establish and maintain private tax favored DC and DB plans for the benefit of the employer’s workforce. The desired outcome is that retired workers would have access to the required financial resources during retirement.

I am always concerned when our leaders seek to improve our lives. Granted, as a nation, Americans are not the best savers, rather we are consumers. We are also facing long term and tough decisions concerning our national debt and the continued funding of entitlement programs such as Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. Congressionally requested studies with titles such as “Private Pensions: Some Key Features Lead to an Uneven Distribution of Benefits” make me uneasy. The same legislative acts and regulations which permitted the deployment of DC plans have allowed some employers to freeze, cut-back, and terminate cohort DB plans.  It will be interesting to see what, if any, actions are taken in the coming months with regards to new proposed private pension legislation.

Friday, May 20, 2011

Employee Recognition Program: Trends, Prevalence, and Effectiveness

Friday, May 20, 2011

In January 2011 WorldatWork, a not-for-profit organization providing education, conferences and research focused on global human resources issues, conducted a survey of some 5,600 members on issues dealing with employee recognition programs. Following responses from 677 members in the US, Canada, and other countries, the results were published in May 2011.

Employee recognition programs address a broad range of activities from length of service to programs to stimulating certain behaviors to strengthening employee attendance. While such programs may include cash as one of many forms of reward, employee recognition programs are not to be confused with incentive and bonus plans. WorldatWork reports that over 80% of employers surveyed reported at least one employee recognition program in the period from 2009 to 2011, with the prevalence in 2011 at 86%. Programs fall into several general classifications, such as:

• Service
• Performance
• Peer‐to‐peer
• Retirement
• Sales performance
• Programs to motivate specific behaviors
• Employee of the year, month, etc.
• Suggestions/ideas
• Major family event
• Safety performance
• Attendance

While the survey did not query organizational employees directly, respondents were asked to gauge the effectiveness of recognition programs in four areas:

• Satisfaction
• Motivation
• Engagement
• Retention

The effectiveness of recognition programs in impacting employee satisfaction(64%), motivation(66%), and engagement(71%) were all rated above 50% as having either an extremely positive or positive effect, only retention(42%) fell below 50%. Respondents report the median recognition program budget at 1% of payroll.

Taken on face value, relative effectiveness measures in the low 60% to the low 70% appears to be modest at best. Certainly, 42% for retention questions whether there is value in continuing such programs without a major redesign of the program and its communication plans. Also somewhat interesting is that over a period of 9 years, the prevalence of recognition programs has remained at or above the 80% level .in spite of changes in the economy.

Bob Nelson, author of “1001 Ways to Reward Employees”, “Keeping Up in a Down Economy”, and other works, is the founder of Nelson Motivation, Inc., and co-funder of the National Association for Employee Recognition. In “1001 Ways” he cites examples of the various ways in which organizations and individuals recognize others. Examples include “Thank You’s” written on business cards, candy bars, newsletters pinpointing achievements, publication of the accomplishments of employees’ children.

How effective can simple forms of recognition be when compared to tangible rewards such as cash or a large ticket prize? To start with, it would be difficult to separate the effects of recognition and motivation as drivers in modifying behavior. Maslow argued that we as humans strive for a sense of recognition and achievement from those around us including our families, friends, employers, and co-workers.  If this is the case, even the simple act of thanking someone for a job well done carries a degree of value. To add greater value, that acknowledgement should occur within a public setting such as a staff or departmental meeting.