Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Competency Model Construction, Retro-Fit

Thursday, March 25, 2010

We briefly reviewed how you might construct a competency model from the ground floor up for a single job in the example of a long distance truck driver. It was clear that such an effort would require a significant amount of resources in time and manpower, which translates into financial demands. Many organizations would not be welling to investment the required level of assets into developing a brand new competency model for one job much less for several jobs. It is possible to obtain a readymade competency model that may fit 70%-80% of an organization’s needs, while allowing for customization of the remaining 30%-20%. A quick search of the internet finds numerous sites offering consulting services related to competency models. Many web-based model-building tools use interactive wizards to allow the user to construct a model online in real time. A similar search at Amazon.com, found a number of books on competency models that would help the HR profession gain insight into how competency models would be useful to their organization.

While I will not endorse any specific website, vendor or book, I am listing a few here as examples of what is available. The reader should exercise their own due diligence in selecting the materials and tools best suited for their unique situation.

Websites:

American Society for Training & Development: http://www.astd.org/content/research/competency/

Halogen Software Inc.: http://www.halogensoftware.com/
Workitect, Inc.: http://www.workitect.com/competency_systems.html

CareerOneStop: http://www.careeronestop.org/competencymodel/

Books:

The Art and Science of Competency Models: Pinpointing Critical Success Factors in Organizations by Anntoinette D. Lucia and Richard Lepsinger (Hardcover - Mar. 5, 1999)

The Handbook of Competency Mapping: Understanding, Designing and Implementing Competency Models in Organizations (Response Books) by Seema Sanghi (Hardcover - Dec. 2003)

Competence at Work: Models for Superior Performance by Signe M. Spencer and Lyle M. Spencer (Hardcover - Mar. 1993)

Using Competency Models to Manage Firm Talent by Heather Bock (Paperback - Jan. 25, 2007)
Leadership competency models [An article from: The Leadership Quarterly] by G.P. Hollenbeck, M.W. McCall, and R.F. Silzer (Digital - Aug. 1, 2006) – HTML
Constructing Core Competencies: Using Competency Models to Manage Firm Talent by Heather Bock and Robert Ruyak (Kindle Edition - Aug. 11, 2009)

There are potential trade offs in one of more of a competency model’s features, effectiveness, reliability or validity when applied to an unintended job or function. A model developed for a sales team in the food and beverage industry may be adapted for a sales team in software sales, but how valid could it be? Furthermore, a competency model does not stand alone within the organization. Sustaining it are the reward, recognition, training, development, and management support systems. Competency model development is an ongoing, evolutionary process rather than a fire and forget, check it off the list, one time accomplishment.







Monday, March 29, 2010

Competency Model Construction, New

Wednesday, March 24, 2010
 
There are two ways to approach the creation of almost anything, build new from the foundation up or purchase something already created and modify it to meet your needs. This is true for houses, organizations, software systems, and competency models. What would be required to build a new fully functional, validated competency model for, let us say for a long distance truck driver? We would need to know what a long distance truck driver does, when, where, how, why, and who does the work. Furthermore, we would want to know the frequency of the work and the importance of the work to the overall success of driving a truck. As a designer, we would want to talk to drivers, their managers, their mechanics, and others. A good idea may be to ride along with drivers and observe them in various situations, times of day, locations, and weather conditions. Lastly, all of this “data” would require analysis and formulation into an initial and tentative model, with preliminary testing for reliability and validation with subject matter experts.
 
Using the example of a long distance truck driver we would collect data on the type of truck, engine and transmission specifications, trailer type, number of drive axles and non-drive axles, mileage driven, tonnage delivered, geographical area driven, type of driver assignment, i.e., single or team, typical weather and traffic conditions, number of stops or trailer drops, hazardous vs. non-hazardous cargos, safety records, and types of cargo. It is possible that much of this data is available from the organization’s data management system(s).
 
Interviewing drivers could prove to be challenging as many may be on the road and inaccessible for long periods. Some type of online (many drivers now file their logs electronically) questionnaires could prove to be helpful when interviewees are not housed in a central location. Interviewing drivers after returning to their home depot might be an alternative, if you allow for the drivers to rest after driving 5,000 miles in five days. As with any job, managers would be a key subject for interviewing. Mechanics could be useful in identifying the types of drivers who take better care of their trucks, i.e., lower maintenance cost, down times, repairs … etc. Interviewing hundreds of drivers could be time communing and expensive, requiring a team of interviewers. The very nature of an interview could alter the behaviors of the drivers, for the better or for the worst. The option of hosting focus groups with drivers could be as much of a challenge as interviewing individual drivers. Job diaries and journaling might be an alternative means to collect specific details about examples of certain events, traffic, accidents, weather … etc.
 
Riding “shot-gun” with drivers could certainly add a personal perspective to the boredom, lonely hours, and monotonous conditions of driving thousands of miles each trip. It would further help to understand the issues associated with traffic stops, weight stations, inspections, accidents, city driving vs. interstate, weather conditions, trailer drops, cargo loading and unloading wait times. However, this could also alter the driver’s behavior. The use of remote video recordings could support the observation of drivers at their home depots as they enter, prepare for, and leave for another run.
 
Once all these data points and observations have been collected and organized, some form of analysis will follow to identify and separate outstanding, average, and poor performers. Following the initial data collection, organization, and initially analysis, preliminary validation of the data will require review by managers and other subject matter experts. “Others” might include individuals such as, driver recruiters, mechanics, diver trainers, dispatchers, depot managers, material handlers, forklift operators, and other drivers. The goal, at this point is to gain a consensus among the various groups as to what constitutes outstanding, average, and poor performance of a driver. With this consensus, we should have enough tentative information to construct a model of driver behaviors to support selecting, training, evaluating, rewarding, and managing drivers.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Project Planning Competency Modeling

Tuesday, March 23, 2010


It should not have to be said, but I will, “Plan Your Work, Work Your Plan”.

Developing and/or implementing a competency model demands a significant amount of resource preparation and requires basic project management skills, as would any other major organizational effort. In these times of limited resource availability and multiple duty assignments, no one has the luxury of unnecessary steps or wasted actions. Depending on the scope of your implementation someone will need to function as the project manager and coordinate, schedule, mange the interviews of dozens of individuals, review dozens of questionnaires, arrange meetings, perform analysis, draft proposals, develop communications materials, and follow-up with numerous individuals. To make all of this to happen in an orchestrated fashion, a plan of sufficient details is vital to the success of the undertaking. The goals and objectives of the implementation should be clear and concise as to the business justification for the endeavor, the impact on product lines, functions, jobs or locations, the methodology for the model’s creation, and identification of the roles and responsibilities of team members.

Many organizations have internal or even external guidelines, which dictate how any enterprise-wide project is developed, funded, and deployed. These guidelines may deal with the planning tools used, how resources are allocated, the use of steering committees, how outcomes are measured, and who or what has finial approval of the project. Detailed project plans that itemize every conceivable step during an implementation are the norm for many organizations. My own experience tells me that senior organizational leaders generally do not want a review of low-level detail. A summary of the major steps generally is acceptable for the C-team members with milestones and overall time periods clearly identified. Whatever level of detail is common in your organization is your target, however; it should clearly identify individual team members’ roles and responsibilities.


With any project plan, it is essential to identify possible roadblocks and alternatives to facilitate moving past any obstacles. These roadblocks could be include, the unavailability of key resources, an unanticipated competing organizational initiative, changes in the management team, and changes in the financial position of the company, to name but a few. A well-developed plan will help to identify potential barriers and allow for alternative planning steps, if encountered. Example, if a new member of management joins the organization, there should be a plan in place to provide background, bring then up to speed on the status of the project, their role and responsibility, and any impact on their functional unit(s). One planning technique is to build a small amount of “pad” time to allow for any project slippage caused by impediments. This will at least allow you to meet your overall plan deadline without a major work stoppage. One major subsection of the project plan is a communications plan. It is common for planners to under estimate the resources required to develop, gain approval, prepare, and fulfill communications materials. Since most large employers have some level of access to marketing and/or commications resources, either internally or externally, coordination of these resources requires significant efforts.

While the project manager of an enterprise-wide replacement of a Payroll-HRMS-Financial system, someone on my team came up with the idea to give everyone who completed the end-user training a pin-on button reading, “Mission Ready”. This sent the message to others that training was important and helped to “brand” the Payroll-HRMS-Financial system. While an e-mail, blast may pass as communications in some organizations, the success or failure of many projects hinge on your target audiences’ acceptance of a well-crafted message from creditable sources.

In these unpredictable times, priorities and plans must change to accommodate new demands from the market place. Any project must allow for a change in direction, reallocation of resources, and scope.

Monday, March 22, 2010

The Role of Competency Modeling in HRM

Monday, March 22, 2010

It continues to be evident, even in the current economic times, acquiring and retaining the “right” talent is fundamental to the success of every organization. The role of competency modeling is to help organizations find and manage the “right” mix of strategic management and professional talent required for that success. Competency modeling provides that support by linking talent acquisition, training, appraisal, reward, and succession planning to the short and long-term goals of businesses by identifying the key critical success factors for specific roles. While it is possible to apply competency modeling to an entire organization, it is also feasible to apply it to specific units, product lines, locations or a select few essential functions.

During the selection process, the right candidate must be selected for the right reasons. Seldom do organizations have the luxury of hiring an employee just because they “look good” or they have the correct pedigree. In these times of lean and leaner staffs, every member of the business unit must often perform multiple functions, usually starting on day one. Therefore, it is vital that all members of the interviewing team be on the same page when looking for those factors that will allow the new hire to be successful or point to immediate failure. Through the discovery process, competency modeling identifies those factors central to the success of the candidate and provides a road map to link the right candidate to the right role during the interviewing phase.

While employers expect the new hire to be fully trained prior to joining the organization, ongoing training and development is still an essential function in the continuing growth of high potential members of a business’s leadership team. Since competency modeling has identified the key success factors for the role and has helped to select the right candidate, those same factors need to be reinforced in the behavior of the leadership team member. Furthermore, should developmental issues be noticed in a key team member, competency modeling will help to identify them and provide a means to correct them effectively and efficiently? Competency modeling does this by allowing the organization to focus its limited training, development, and coaching resources on those skills and behaviors that are vital to the individual’s organizational success.

Employee performance appraisal is often an uncomfortable time for the employee as well as the manager. At appraisal time, competency modeling again provides the organization and incumbent with a clear picture of what performance behaviors will be scrutinized and considered as a means of measuring success or failure. It also provides for a means of focusing the appraisal conversation around issues that are significant to both the organization and incumbent. Should the organization uncover any training, developmental, and coaching needs of the incumbent during the appraisal process, competency modeling will validate whether those needs are critical to the incumbent’s success.

Regardless of how it takes place, voluntarily, involuntarily, promotion, demotion or reassignment; all employees eventually exit their current roles. Succession planning is fundamental to a robust HRM system and the continuation of business activities. By now, the role of competency modeling should be clear. It illuminates those key knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits vital to identifying a replacement as well as the assessment of an incumbent for their next organizational role in the case of demotion, promotion or reassignment. Moreover, it provides for a means to assess the strength and weaknesses of the incumbent’s prior direct reports and their readiness for their next move.

Although competency modeling is but a single tool in the organization’s toolkit, nevertheless it is critical in the HRM system of talent acquisition, development, appraisal, reward, and succession planning for organizations who wish to participate in today’s aggressive business environment.

Friday, March 19, 2010

Basics of Competency Modeling

Friday, March 19, 2010

As organizations continue to struggle with increased competition, shortages of strategic management and professional talent, and pressure from shareholders to produce tangible returns, some organizations are beginning to rethink all aspects of their talent management system. While “competency models” were once thought of as the purview of academicians and scholarly work, human resource professional are reconsider the role competency modeling plays in the acquisition, retention, and succession planning of key managers and professionals. In these times of economic downturn, it is easy for the HR professional to assume that high quality strategic talent is abundant on every street corner. As businesses emerge from “The Great Recession”, many are looking to grow new and re-build lost or diminished markets. The identification and formalization of those knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits necessary to achieve sustained success and growth is essential to a talent acquisition system founded on competency modeling.



The identification of core knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits possessed by top, average, and low performers must be identified and built into an organization’s talent management system as a means of binding the success of both parties. Talent management is as much about selecting the right candidate for the right job as it about de-selecting the wrong candidate for the right reasons. While there are numerous methods available for the collection and building of a skill’s database, i.e., knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits, it is the validation of those skills and their association with job performance success or failure that is essential. Depending on the size of the organization, the size of the talent pool sampled, and the financial and time resources available, the organization may choose personal incumbent and manager interviews, focus groups, job shadowing, questionnaires or even video/tele-conferencing as a means of data collection. The key is to capture and validate via position managers examples of work performance at all three levels that will allow those critical factors to be built into the talent management system.



Consider a Pediatric Nurse providing care in the patient’s residential home rather than a hospital setting. No massive hospital staff to back them up in an emergency, maybe the parents are home, maybe not; maybe the home is many miles from 911 assistance. The knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits required in this setting are entirely different from those needed in an institutional environment. A competency model can be used to vet out those skills of a superior, average or not so average nurse and link those skills into the selection, retention, training, and succession talent management process for that position. Getting at those key skills means looking at examples of job related performance and determining situations when it leads to success or failure. This requires input from both the nurse and their managers, only they are able to validate the skills required in the various environmental settings the nurses may find themselves.

During the discovery process, it may be uncovered that a home based Pediatric Nurse requires knowledges, skills, abilities, and personality traits not commonly associated with their hospital based counterparts. Many skills thought to be critical for job success or failure are based on the anecdotal assumptions by employees themselves as well as their managers. Competency modeling provides a means to either validate those assumptions or discard them in favor of skills found to be truly essential to the success of the employee and the organization.



Thursday, March 11, 2010

Status of Health Care Reform

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Within the last few days, the heat on health care reforms appears to be picking up steam.

A recent Associated Press poll reported on March 9, 2010 found that 50% of those polled want health care reformed, however 68% say they want change supported by both parties and that President Obama and Democrats should work with Republicans.

Results of an Investor's Business Daily (IBD) released on March 8, 2010 found that 61% of those surveyed want Congress start over and not rely on "reconciliation" to pass unilaterally any health care reform measures. The poll, conducted by TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence, for IBD, found that most polled “are dismayed with the way the debate has played out”.

As reported by Margaret Talev and David Lightman, for the McClatchy-Tribune News Service on March 9, 2010 health care reform is drawing actions from both supporters and protesters. Public-option groups are pushing Congress to pass reform including a public option while members of the Tea Party are seeking a rejection of health care legislation. While Democrats report they may not be able to pass any final measure by March 26, Republicans are attempting stall any further action on reform. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce reports it plans to spend upwards of $10 million to convince the public and others that the current plan is bad for the economy and jobs.

Alan Fram, an Associated Press writer, reported on March 10, 2010 that Republicans might have a difficult time defeating efforts by the Democrats to pass health care reform via the reconciliation procedures. In hopes of fast tracking reform, Democrats in the Senate could use “reconciliation” to block any Republican efforts to filibuster reform to a standstill. With reconciliation, Democrats would only need 41 of the Senate’s 100 votes to fend off a Republican filibuster. Latest reports indicate that Democrats have 59 votes in the Senate to counter the Republicans 41.

Erica Werner, of The Associated Press on March 10, 2010, reported that President Obama plans to continue to push up the pressure on “skittish Democrats” to act quickly on his health care reform agenda. During a planned speech in St. Louis on Wednesday, he plans to urge Congress to move and move quickly on health care reform. The St. Louis speech is the second address on health care the President has made within three days.

The Targeted News Service on March 9, 2010, reported that Governor Bill Richardson of New Mexico signed two state health care bills into law.

HB 12 - Health Insurer Service Reimbursement: Requires insurance companies to spend 85% of premiums or more on direct member services and not on administration or profit.

SB 148 - No use of Gender for Health Insurance Rating: Requires the use of unisex insurance rate tables for the individual market, prohibiting the use of separate premium tables for males and females.

It remains to be seen whether President Obama and Democrats have the ability or will to pass health care reform in the face of strong oppression from Republicans, business and public groups, and many voters.