Non-Profit Organizations Facing Brain Drain

Friday, December 27, 2013

 

Non-profit organizations (NPO’s), including religious, educational, philanthropic, health care, labor unions, and professional associations are facing a critical talent drain as Baby Boomers retire over the next five years.  A recent study [highlights] by the Plan Sponsor Council of America and sponsored by the Principal Financial Group reports that almost 70% of NPO’s will be forced to replace most retirees and over a third will report difficulties finding replacements.  Over 50% of NPO’s project they will lose 10% to 20% of their workforce to retirement.  While the study focused on 403(b) plan design, eligibility, participation, and administration, the study points to a serious pending loss of talent.  The survey is available for purchase at:  2013 403(b) Plan Survey.

 

Faced with such a significant loss of talent, NPO’s will have to go head-to-head with for-profit organizations to acquire the required talent to meet their missions.  While there has always been a tug-of-war between private for-profit and non-profit organizations, however with both sectors feeling the burn of Baby Boomers’ forthcoming retirements, talent acquisition and retention will take on an increased sense of urgency.  Candidates with advanced degrees in the sciences have typically leaned towards schools of higher learning for teaching and research opportunities, those same skills are increasingly sought by the private sector.  Organizations such as Bain& Company actively seek masters and PHD level applicants for consulting and internship positions, the same candidates often sought out at many NPO’s.

 

Organizations cannot compete for talent solely on the merits of their benefits and retirement plans.  Even the most altruistic candidate can be swayed by cash and non-cash opportunities, as well as work culture.  Both for-profit and non-profit employers will be faced with the challenge to present applicants with a total package.  This challenge will demand a new level of flexibility in the design and administration of the employer-employee relationship.  Organizations will be faced with situations which necessitate the retention of their current talent while acquiring their replacements.  Phased retirement could be one tool smooth the transition from an employee with decades of service to their replacement.  Many of us entered the workplace in a “phased” manner, working part-time, summer jobs, internships, and finally full-time employment.

 

While the loss of organizational talent is not a pleasant prospect, it does bring with it the opportunity to re-design and re-invent how work is done for many employers, including NPO’s.  Concepts such as Creative Destruction can be applied to job level tasks in an effort to bring about workplace change from “we have always done it that way”.  A self-managed and cross-functional team culture could appeal to the mind-set of many Generation X and Y cohorts as potential Baby Boomer replacements.  Finally, leveraging of technology for non-profits is just as vital as it is for their for-profit counterparts if they are to focus on their mission.