Showing posts with label Fair Labor Standards Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fair Labor Standards Act. Show all posts

Friday, April 1, 2011

US Supreme Court Finds Oral Complaints are protected under Labor, Fair Labor Standards Act, Anti-Retaliation

Friday, April 01, 2011

On March 22, 2011 the US Supreme Court ruled that oral complaints made directly to an employer are to be considered protected behaviors under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) § 215(a)(3) of the Act. Citing numerous examples of the use of oral complaint procedures allowed in local, state, Federal rules and regulations, as well as legislative and judicial processes; the Court concluded that both written and orally presented directly to an employer are to be afforded the same level of protection.

Kevin Kasten, a former employee of the Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corporation was discharged for failing to clock in and out on numerous occasions while employed at Saint-Gobain. Kasten alleged that he was discharged in retaliation for making oral complaints to Saint-Gobain about the placement of time cloaks. Kasten’s complaints dealt with the time clock’s placement that failed to allow for the recording donning and doffing time to put on and take off protective clothing at the beginning and ending of work shifts. Prior decisions by the courts have held that such donning and doffing time is to be considered time worked requiring workers to be paid.

The Court cited that at the time of the Act’s passage, “20.8% of manufacturing laborers in 1940 had less than five years” of education. Thus to require only written complaints would have imposed a significant hardship on such workers. Saint-Gobain countered that to protect oral complaints would expose employers to “a state of uncertainty about whether an employee (particularly an employee who seems unusually angry at the moment) is in fact making a complaint about an Act violation or just letting off steam”. Nevertheless, the Court concluded that the Seventh Circuit erred, sent the case back to the lower court, and vacated the Circuit court’s judgment.

How will any organization separate and distinguish between an employee “just letting off steam” and a valid and concerted compliant? First, every organization should have fully vetted policy in place to address employee complaints whether written or oral. Second, supervisory and management team members need to be trained in the handling of employee complaints. Third, organizational policies addressing employee complaints should be well communicated to current and prospective employees. Fourth, every “compliant” should be taken seriously, investigated thoroughly, and well documented. Does this impose an undue burden upon the organization? Yes, it does, but so does the thousands of dollars spent on legal fees, lost productivity, and the potential for fines, penalties, recovery of lost wages, loss or employee and community goodwill.

Kevin Kasten was discharged from Saint-Gobain’s Portage, Wisconsin facility in December 2006. Since that time Saint-Gobain’s management and its legal team have most likely spent hundreds of hours defending their position over the placement of the time clocks when earlier court decisions clearly indicated that donning and doffing time is to be considered time worked requiring workers are to be paid for that time. Furthermore, all evidence indicated that Kasten had raised the issue of time clock placement on numerous occasions over the three years he worked for Saint-Gobain. Had Saint-Gobain addressed the issue early on in Kasten’s employment, Saint-Gobain would not have been faced with public exposure in Seventh Circuit, the Supreme Court, and now a repeat of the entire process.

While I am sure that Saint-Gobain is well known for many innovative services, products, and processes within their industry; I am not sure that they what to be known for landmark decisions in the area of employment and employee relations, particularly when they were on the losing side of those decisions.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Labor, Fair Labor Standards Act, Anti-Retaliation

Friday, March 18, 2011

And you thought that the Fair Labor Standards Act only dealt with minimum wage and overtime!

Kevin Kasten, an employee of Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics, Corp., filed suit claiming that Saint-Gobain ended his employment due to his objections to the location of the company's timekeeping clocks. Citing that Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) § 215(a)(3) of the Act protects workers from employer retaliation, even for making oral complaints, Kasten filed suit in 2009. On the other hand, Saint-Gobain states that the FLSA only provides protections in the case of written complaints and only when those complaints are made to governmental agencies. In an earlier decision, the Seventh Circuit agreed with the employer. Subsequently, Kasten appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court who will hear the case sometime in early 2011. If the Court overturns the Circuit’s decision, informal employer-employee complaints could allow workers to raise workplace grievances verbally without fear of retaliation.

At issue is the placement of the company’s time clocks, which requires Saint-Gobain employees to “suit-up” by donning and doffing their protective gear before clocking in and clocking out. Kastsen argued that time spending donning and doffing protective gear should have been “time worked” under FLSA. However, the placement of the time clocks prevented recording donning and doffing time. After numinous oral and written warnings and suspensions for failing to properly clock in and clock out, Kasten was terminated. After being terminated, Kasten sued Saint-Gobain stipulating that the company retaliated against him for his verbal complaints to supervisors, which he aurgered was a protected action under FLSA.

Fair Labor Standards Act states that “it shall be unlawful for any person”, § 215(a)(3), reads: ”(3) to discharge or in any other manner discriminate against any employee because such employee has filed any complaint or instituted or caused to be instituted any proceeding under or related to this chapter, or has testified or is about to testify in any such proceeding, or has served or is about to serve on an industry committee;”. Apparently, the Seventh Circuit agreed with the employer that a verbal complaint did not meet the test of “filing” a complaint. Thus when the Supreme Court hears the case in early 2011, will they agree or disagree that “filing” may be accomplished verbally as well as in writing?

While this case may seem much to do about nothing, the time, energy, costs, lost goodwill, lost productivity, distraction, and pure frustration is anything but insignificant. If Saint-Gobain’s goal was to avoid paying for “twenty minutes" to "2.5 hours of pay per week” as alleged by Kasten, legal fees alone have passed that threshold or will do so very soon. If the Supreme Court returns the case to the lower court, both parties could be at this for some time into the future.

According to Saint-Gobain’s website, they are “a Paris-based multinational corporation with more than 350 years of engineered materials” experience. Saint-Gobain is in the top “52” industrial companies “in the world with € 43.8 billion in sales, 205,000 employees in 59 countries”, and produces “more than 20,000 products”.